Dog bark collars come in three versions, each of them using an unique mechanism of inhibiting dog barking. All of them work, but there is some debate as to whether these collars are ethical to use. If you own a noisy dog, you need to get informed on the options you have available.
Citronella Spray Collars
This type of no bark collars pulverize citrus substance under the dog’s chin if it barks for too long. The citrus spray collar is very effective because most dogs dislike this smell. Some citronella collars use two methods to prevent the dog from barking – first they make a warning hissing sound, prior to the spraying itself. If the dog stops barking, the spraying will not occur. The citrus spray collars do not hurt the dog, they merely annoy it.
Ultrasonic or Sonic Bark Collars
The sound produced by sonic or ultrasonic devices is only heard by dogs. This sound is like the one created by dog whistles. Most humans can’t hear it or be annoyed by it, but dogs can and will stop barking once they realize that when they stop barking the high pitched tone goes away. Experts confirm that this device is not harmful for the dog. Once again, there is no pain involved – it’s just a bit annoying for the dog. Sonic collars are not as efficient as the other bark collars because the dog can easily get used to the sound and ignore it.
Electronic No Bark Collars
An electronic bark collar reacts at the dog’s barking by sending it a mild shock. It isn’t truly dangerous, and can be compared to the shock you can get from static electricity. Once again, mostly just an annoyance – but this is the type of no bark collar that some people believe is unethical. Their opinion is based on the fact that, unlike the other types of collars, this electronic device does more than annoying the dog – it applies a physical stimulus. There are persons who do not approve with these devices. However, the electronic dog collar does a great job in calming down your dog so, if you are a dog owner and your dog never ceases to bark, you may as well consider buying a bark collar.
As a dog owner, you can choose from three versions of no bark dog collars – the electronic one, the sonic or ultrasonic device or the citrus bark collar. Citronella spray and sonic or ultrasonic sounds are considered ethical, but electronic shock collars are sometimes considered unethical because of the shocking. None of these methods are considered dangerous for dogs.
no bark collars have gained more and more popularity lately, because of their efficacy in teaching your dog how to behave. However, some people consider the electronic dog collar unethical, because it uses electronic shocks to calm the barking. It is up to you to choose the most proper method to educate your dog. You should know that no matter which dog collar you choose, it will not harm your dog, but merely annoy it. If you want to read more about no bark dog collars and why they are so safe for your dog’s health, click this link.
No Bark Collars – Ethical or Not? is a post from: Bichon Frise Guide